The Supreme Court has acquitted a man charged with rape after finding that the prosecution failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.

Judge Oliver Abraham Saksak Oliver delivered the written decision on Monday, confirming an earlier oral ruling made at the end of the trial.

The defendant, John William of Imae village on Tanna, had been charged with one count of sexual intercourse without consent under sections 90 and 91 of the Penal Code Act (Vanuatu).

He pleaded not guilty to the charge.

The trial took place last week before Judge Saksak, with Lenry Young appearing for the Public Prosecutor and Harrison Rantes representing William.

During the trial, the prosecution called one witness, the complainant who told the court that the incident occurred at her home in 2023.

She alleged that the defendant forced her to have sexual intercourse with her. She later reported the incident to her father and to police.

Under cross-examination, the complainant acknowledged that the defendant had asked her for sex while they were in the kitchen area, which had no door.

William, giving evidence in his defence, maintained that the encounter was consensual and denied forcing or threatening her.

Judge Saksak noted that the defendant admitted that sexual intercourse had taken place, leaving the main issue for the court was to determine whether there was consent.

In assessing the evidence, the judge found the defendant’s account more credible and said the complainant’s evidence had been weakened during cross-examination.

The judge ruled that the prosecution had not proved beyond reasonable doubt that sexual intercourse occurred without consent or that the defendant lacked a reasonable belief that the complainant had consented.

“The evidence does not establish force, threats or intimidation,” the judge said.

The court returned a verdict of not guilty and ordered William’s immediate release from custody.

The written judgment was issued at Isangel on Tanna.


SOURCE: VANUATU DAILY POST